| 1960 FIRST TEAM | |||||
| Position | Name | School | Height | Weight | Year |
| C | Dick Fernando | Wakefield | 5'10 | 200 | Sr |
| G | Phil Davisson | Escanaba | 6'2 | 195 | Sr |
| G | John Iafolla | Ironwood | 5'10 | 178 | Sr |
| T | Ron Peters | Marquette | 5'11 | 210 | Sr |
| T | Jack Schinderle | Iron River | 5'10 | 210 | Sr |
| E | Tom Butler | Escanaba | 5'11 | 180 | Sr |
| E | Don Anderson | Newberry | 6'2 | 185 | Sr |
| B | Tim Bullock | Marquette | 6'0 | 168 | Sr |
| B | Raoul Robar | Ishpeming | 5'9 | 185 | Sr |
| B | Ken Perry | St Ignace | 5'11 | 175 | Sr |
| B | Bob Rosemurgy | Escanaba | 5'7 | 165 | Sr |
| 1960 SECOND TEAM | |||||
| Position | Name | School | Height | Weight | Year |
| C | Bill Thexton | Ishpeming | 6'2 | 216 | Sr |
| G | Mike Seldon | L'Anse | 5'10 | 185 | Sr |
| G | Joe Sanchez | Wakefield | 5'8 | 155 | Sr |
| T | Frak Sabor | Holy Name | 5'11 | 190 | Sr |
| T | Don Koski | Ironwood | 6'0 | 185 | Sr |
| E | Perry Smith | Ironwood | 6'2 | 185 | Sr |
| E | Tom Berand | Houghton | 6'3 | 170 | Sr |
| B | Tom Miheve | Wakefield | 5'11 | 155 | Sr |
| B | Pete Johnson | Menominee | 5'8 | 146 | Sr |
| B | Pat Scanlon | Iron Mountain | 5'9 | 160 | Sr |
| B | Bob Erickson | Wakefield | 5'11 | 165 | Sr |
| 1960 SPECIAL AWARDS |
| Barber Trophy - WAKEFIELD CARDINALS |
| Coach of the Year - Al Sigman, Escanaba |